NEW ENERGY WILL SAVE MILITARY LIVES - STUDY
Energy Security – America’s Best Defense; A study of increasing dependence on fossil fuels in wartime, and its contribution to ever higher casualty rates
November 9, 2009 (Deloitte)
and
Pentagon could save lives by cutting fuel use-study
Andrea Shalal-Esa, November 10, 2009 (Reuters)
SUMMARY
Commanders in Iraq have been saying for several years now that the military's dependence on oil is a crippling weakness that is getting U.S. troops killed.
Energy Security – America’s Best Defense; A study of increasing dependence on fossil fuels in wartime, and its contribution to ever higher casualty rates, by General Charles F. Wald (USAF Ret) and Tom Captain (Deloitte Vice Chair), documents the 175% increase in fuel consumption by the military in the decades since the Vietnam War, at a rate of 2.6% per year. It demonstrates how implementing New Energy and Energy Efficiency can reduce the numbers of convoys needed to deliver to fuel in battle theaters and other dangerous places and thereby reduce the lives lost and bodies maimed in service to feeding this nation's unnecessary oil addiction.
A key conclusion of the study is that the effort in Afghanistan could see a 124% increase in U.S. casualties through 2014 if the military does not move to New Energy and Energy Efficiency.
click to enlargeCOMMENTARY
The Deloitte study examined energy use by the military from World War II to the current wars in Middle Asia. The 2.6% increase in consumption per year and 175% increase since the Vietnam War has resulted in the military’s present use of 22 gallons of fuel per day per soldier due to:
1-increased mechanization of war technology,
2-increased expeditionary operations using mobility over long distances, and
3-irregular operations in rugged terrain.
The military has adopted more efficient internal combustion and jet engines and for its armored vehicles, tanks and planes, as well as nuclear power for aircraft carriers and submarines but the sheer multiplying of vehicle and operation numbers has outstripped the advances in old technologies.
click to enlargeConvoys must often traverse long distances over treacherously hostile IED- and roadside bomb-compromised ground to deliver vital fuel. Only the introduction of methods to reduce dependence on these convoys will prevent casualties in Afghanistan and Iraq from increasing 17.5% per year for a cumulative increase of 124% through 2014.
But New Energy and Energy Efficiency technologies offer the opportunity to change the game in the military’s favor. The report mentions wind and solar energies, alternative fuels from algae and biomass, the use of battery electric vehicles and experimental concepts such as fission, fusion and fuel cells. Such technologies offer the opportunity not only to save lives but to help move the world to emissions-free energy and improve the economics of the military equation as well.
click to enlargeFrom statistics on the military’s use of oil, the study moves to the world’s increasing dependence on oil, citing International Energy Agency predictions that world oil use will rise from today’s 85 million barrels per day to 94.4 million barrels per day in 2015 and 106.4 million barrels per day in 2030. This dependence is leading to the exhaustion of economically extractable oil reserves and driving the cost of fuel to unaffordable levels.
With its consumption of nearly 20 million barrels per day, the U.S. makes itself dependent on countries that are largely “unstable or prone to conflict” and expends enormous reserves of its blood and treasure protecting its supply. As the single biggest user of oil in the U.S., the Department of Defense (DoD) is the most vulnerable of all to the costs. In 2008, DoD spent $16 billion for 120 million barrels of oil, a million barrels every 3 days.
click to enlargeThe Air Force uses the most. Weapons and war tools use an ever bigger portion. In 2008, 2.1 million barrels of fuel per month (90 million gallons) went to Iraq and Afghanistan.
Dependence on oil makes the U.S. and the U.S. military vulnerable along a specific set of “lines of communication (LOC)” at a specific set of “chokepoints:”
1-the Straits of Hormuz in the Persian Gulf (the most important chokepoint in the world because it sees 17 million barrels of oil go through every day),
2-the Strait of Malacca near Indonesia in the Indian Ocean,
3-the Suez Canal leading from the Red Sea to the Mediterranean Sea,
4-the Panama Canal connecting the Pacific Ocean, through the Caribbean Sea, to the Atlantic Ocean,
5-Bab el-Mandeb on the West Coast of Africa, and
6-the Bosporus/Turkish Straits connecting the Mediterranean to Central Asia and Russia.
click to enlarge2008 costs due to Improvised Explosive Devices (IEDs), enemy attacks, rough weather, traffic accidents and pilferage: 44 trucks, 220,000 gallons of fuel. IEDs caused 43% of U.S. deaths in Iraq from July 2003 to May 2009. For much of the 2005 to 2008 period, IEDs caused more than half of all U.S. deaths in Iraq.
From 2005 to 2009, IEDs caused 38% of U.S. deaths in Afghanistan and the numbers are climbing with the level of activity. In July and August 2009, numbers were 50% higher than all of 2007.
The military is paying between $2 and $3 per gallon for fuel but when the cost of getting it to in-theater destinations is included, the cost is about $15 per gallon and when the cost of protecting it is included, the cost is about $45 per gallon.
click to enlargeThe 2008 Energy Security Strategic Plan from DoD’s Energy Security Task Force set 4 goals:
1-Maintain/enhance operational effectiveness while cutting total energy demand,
2-Increase strategic resilience with alternative and assured fuels and energy,
3-Enhanced operational/business effectiveness with institutional energy policies and solutions in DoD planning and business practices, and
4-Implement DoD-wide metrics with electric metering by 2012 and natural gas and steam metering by 2016.
click to enlargeThe Report of the Defense Science Board Task Force on DoD Energy Strategy, subtitled “More Fight – Less Fuel,” made 5 recommendations:
1-Increase efficiency and use the full fuel cost to make every decision,
2-Reduce the risk of power interruptions on critical missions and in national infrastructure,
3-Establish DoD-wide metrics and goals,
4-Spend on New Energies and Energy Efficiencies at levels matching their high value,
5-Set policies and incentives to achieve near-term opportunities.
click to enlargeGoals:
For Mobility
1-Turbine engine efficiency
2-UAV and generator efficiency
3-Vehicle efficiency
For Facilities
1-Solar
2-Geothermal
3-Other New Energies (such as ocean energies)
click to enlargeAlternative fuels, power generation and energy strorage
1-Synfuels, limited by the 2007 energy law to those with lower greenhouse gas emissions (GhGs) than oil,
2-biofuels,
3-algae fuels, especially those that can be refined into jet fuels,
4-tactical power systems and generators, including hybrid engines,
5-fuel cell technologies,
6-nuclear fission technologies, and
7-batteries and other energy storage technologies.
click to enlargeUsing stimulus fund money and other financial resources, DoD has almost $2 billion invested in over 2,300 projects.
The Deloitte study recommendations, based on opportunities for accelerated deployment:
1-Common biofuels for aircraft and big engines, including plant and algae biofuels.
2-Hybrid electric/biofuel engines for ground transport, with built-in multiuse generators.
3-Solar technologies that are lightweight and durable for permanent and tent-like structures.
4-Engine/propulsion technologies that require the highest level of innovation.
click to enlargeQUOTES
- Tom Captain, vice chair/Global and U.S. Aerospace & Defense (A&D) leader, Deloitte LLP/report co-author: “It is clear that our dependence on oil and other fossil fuels puts our fighting men and women at risk…We need to find ways to incorporate renewable energy sources to improve conservation and develop new fuels so that our soldiers are as safe as possible.”
- General Charles Wald (USAF Ret), director/senior advisor to the Aerospace & Defense Industry, Deloitte LLP/ co-author: “If the military can reduce its dependence on fossil fuels, it will help solve the strategic vulnerability that results from having such an oil-intense force…Many people in various sectors of the economy are realizing that energy efficiency, conservation and the use of alternative fuels are not just good for the environment, but good for business as well. In this case, it’s the business of protecting American lives.”
click to enlarge- From the report’s conclusion: “As has been the case throughout history, all of these technologies will be applicable far beyond military use. The entire nation is on course for a new energy future, and the DoD is committed to working with existing and new partners to lead the way…First and foremost, energy security is essential to reduce wartime casualties. With the significant numbers of U.S. soldiers supporting the transport, logistics, and deployment of fossil fuel to the front lines, there is a call to action to reduce dependence on oil in war. Energy security is America’s best defense.”




Despite a tempestuous economy and an unexpected oversupply of allowances due to decreased power demand, the EU's emissions trading system has held surprisingly steady and foresees higher prices in the future. (click to enlarge)
Schematic of the concept. (click to enlarge)
This concept fits broadly into the category of Ocean Thermal Energy Conversion in Hawaii but at lakesides and riversides is a form of geothermal cooling. (click to enlarge)
LightSail 1. (click to enlarge)
click thru for a complete NASA report on the concept
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
Two last points: (1) Accounting for all their radioactive accidents makes the economics of nuclear projects even worse. (click to enlarge)
Two last points: (2) With no disrespect for Dr. Cooper, the great and brilliant Amory Lovins has been preaching this sermon for a long time. (click to enlarge)
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click thru to use the SolarCity calculator
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
From a January 2009 report by the Environmental Working Group (click thru for the report)
Health insurance reform has reformed biofuels subsidies. (From a January 2009 report by the Environmental Working Group - click thru for the report)
Pew Research showed New Energy opportunities aleady growing. (click to enlarge)
Pew Research showed New Energy opportunities aleady growing. (click to enlarge)
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
An ASES study shows New Energy opportunities emerging across a wide spectrum in the next 2 decades. (click to enlarge)
An ASES study shows New Energy opportunities emerging across a wide spectrum in the next 2 decades. (click to enlarge)
An ASES study shows New Energy opportunities emerging across a wide spectrum in the next 2 decades. (click to enlarge)
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
It's easy to see why corn ethanol producers would be threatened by algae biofuels producers. (click to enlarge)
An algae field could be like a corn field in the desert. (click to enlarge)
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
What's good for China is good for the U.S.: Manufacturing and jobs, from one end of the nation to the other. (click to enlarge)
There's an unprecedented level of foreign and domestic investment in wind manufacturing and job creation. (click to enlarge)
click to enlarge
click thru for the interactive map and more on the forces of ruin
click to enlarge
One of the Moroccan projects is a pioneering natural gas-solar hybrid plant. (click to enlarge)
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
Look at that resource! (click to enlarge)
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click thru for more details from Curry & Kerlinger, LLC
Mountaintop removal coal mining destroys avian habitat and coal-burning induced climate change will destroy everybody's habitat. (click to enlarge)
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
Key design element: Oversight. (click to enlarge)
Key design elements: Stringent penalties and assessment. (click to enlarge)
click to enlarge
The evidence is simply undeniable. (click to enlarge)
click to enlarge
New Energy is abundant. (click to enlarge)
It's the best deal. (click to enlarge)
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
Apparently not good enough - yet. (click to enlarge)
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
click to enlarge
SeaGen in a strong flow, wake visible. Photo from Dr D Erwin. (click to enlarge)
Typical output. Explanation below. (click to enlarge)





Plug-in Hybrids, The Cars That Will Recharge America
Oil On The Brain


